Abstract
DATA-001 contains exactly 6,236 verses.
Because the total is even, the corpus has two central verse positions:
- position 3,118
- position 3,119
Under DATA-001, those positions are:
| Global position | Verse | RAW words | BODY words |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,118 | 26:186 | 9 | 9 |
| 3,119 | 26:187 | 9 | 9 |
The central positions themselves were reported before Coran Codex and are therefore treated as previously known.
Coran Codex independently reproduces those positions.
A separate deterministic observation is that both central verses contain exactly nine words under both RAW and BODY.
The midpoint and the 9/9-word property must not be conflated: prior art for the midpoint has been established, while exact prior art for the 9/9-word sub-observation has not been established in the present review.
Research Question
Given a Quranic corpus containing exactly 6,236 verse identifiers:
- which verses occupy global positions 3,118 and 3,119?
- what are their word counts under RAW?
- what are their word counts under BODY?
- are the midpoint positions previously reported?
- does the 9/9-word observation support a calibrated rarity claim?
Dataset & Counting Rules
- Dataset: DATA-001
- Methodology: METHOD-001
- Total verses: 6,236
- Views: RAW and BODY
- Central positions:
6236 / 2 = 3118, followed by position3119
Verse positions are determined from the canonical DATA-001 verse order.
No verse is removed by the BODY transformation.
BODY changes only the documented opening Basmala prefix in 112 first verses.
Deterministic Midpoint
The corpus contains:
6,236 verses
Therefore:
6,236 / 2 = 3,118
For an even-length ordered sequence, the two central entries are positions:
- 3,118
- 3,119
The DATA-001 mapping is:
| Position | Verse |
|---|---|
| 3,118 | 26:186 |
| 3,119 | 26:187 |
Thus the two central verses are:
26:186
and
26:187
Central Verse Texts
Verse 26:186 is:
وما أنت إلا بشر مثلنا وإن نظنك لمن الكاذبين
Verse 26:187 is:
فأسقط علينا كسفا من السماء إن كنت من الصادقين
The global positions are determined independently of the word-count observation.
Word Counts
Under RAW:
| Verse | Word count |
|---|---|
| 26:186 | 9 |
| 26:187 | 9 |
Under BODY:
| Verse | Word count |
|---|---|
| 26:186 | 9 |
| 26:187 | 9 |
Therefore the separate word-count observation is:
9 / 9
Both central verses contain nine words under both registered DATA-001 views.
RAW/BODY Robustness
The BODY transformation does not affect either central verse.
Therefore:
- the global positions remain 3,118 and 3,119;
- the verse identifiers remain 26:186 and 26:187;
- the word counts remain 9 and 9.
For this narrow deterministic measurement, RAW and BODY produce identical outputs.
This does not by itself establish statistical rarity.
Prior Art
The general midpoint relationship is previously known.
A publication predating Coran Codex explicitly describes the 6,236-verse total as two halves of 3,118 verses and identifies:
- the end of the first half at 26:186
- the beginning of the second half at 26:187
Accordingly, Coran Codex does not claim discovery of the midpoint positions.
The role of QMR-004 is to reproduce that positional fact independently on DATA-001.
The separate 9/9-word observation must be treated separately.
The present prior-art review has not established that the exact 9/9-word sub-property was previously reported.
Absence of located prior art is not proof of novelty.
Statistical Analysis
QMR-004 does not assign a conventional p-value to the fact that both central verses contain nine words.
The exact historical rarity procedure associated with this observation was not recovered.
A valid probability claim would require a justified model specifying, among other things:
- what corpus structures are allowed to vary;
- what positions could have been selected;
- what word-count equalities were eligible;
- what target counts could have been noticed;
- what other numerical properties were searched.
Without such a model, the equality:
9 / 9
is a deterministic observation, not a calibrated significance result.
Multiple Testing
A midpoint analysis could potentially notice many properties after inspecting the two central verses:
- equal word counts;
- equal letter counts;
- arithmetic properties of the counts;
- verse numbers;
- surah numbers;
- sums and differences;
- lexical properties;
- other numerical coincidences.
The effective historical search family is not recoverable.
For that reason, Coran Codex does not convert the 9/9 observation into a statistical discovery claim.
Interpretation Standard
Fact
Under DATA-001:
- total verse count = 6,236
- global position 3,118 = 26:186
- global position 3,119 = 26:187
- 26:186 contains 9 words under RAW
- 26:187 contains 9 words under RAW
- both remain 9 words under BODY
Statistical interpretation
The midpoint positions are exact deterministic properties of the ordered DATA-001 corpus.
The 9/9-word equality is also deterministic.
No calibrated rarity or corrected significance level is assigned to the 9/9 observation.
Claim
Coran Codex independently reproduces the previously reported midpoint positions:
26:186 / 26:187
It additionally records the separate DATA-001 observation that both contain nine words.
Not claimed
QMR-004 does not establish:
- discovery of the midpoint;
- statistical significance of the 9/9-word equality;
- proof that the 9/9 property is historically novel;
- supernatural origin;
- divine intent or theological significance.
No supernatural or divine conclusion follows from this result.
Why the Status Is Observation
The midpoint itself is previously reported and independently reproduced.
However, QMR-004 also contains the separate 9/9-word observation.
Exact independent prior reproduction of that sub-property has not been established.
Assigning the entire study Reproduced / E4 could therefore imply that every reported component has independent replication.
The study-wide metadata remain deliberately conservative:
Observation / E1
while the text explicitly records that the midpoint itself is independently reproduced.
Limitations
The word count depends on the counting conventions defined by DATA-001.
No statistical null model has been established for the 9/9 observation.
The prior-art conclusion is also asymmetric:
- the midpoint is established as previously known;
- the exact historical status of the 9/9-word sub-property remains unresolved.
These distinctions must remain visible.
Verdict
Status: Observation
Evidence level: E1
Classification: Confirmatory
Novelty: Previously Known
Discovery: No
The positional result is:
6,236 / 2 = 3,118
with:
3,118 -> 26:186
and:
3,119 -> 26:187
Both verses contain:
9 words / 9 words
under RAW and BODY.
The midpoint is previously known.
The 9/9-word observation is recorded separately and is not promoted to a statistical or novelty claim.
Reproducibility
Analysis:
analysis/qmr-004-reconstruction.mjs
Result:
analysis/results/qmr-004-reconstruction.json
Artifact SHA-256:
468C34672E367A8731E74105F3603B44DAA588B1F03DE0F74B37A4C570EE2AC8
The reconstruction artifact was generated twice under frozen code and verified as:
- SHA-256 identical
- byte-for-byte identical
No historical rarity calculation has been reconstructed as a verified result.